John 4:5-26 - Woman at the Well

A religious leader meets Jesus under the cover of darkness.
A morally compromised woman meets him under the blazing sun.

One walks away with more questions.
The other runs away to share good news.

Last week’s passage from John 3 showed us Jesus’ interaction with the Pharisee Nicodemus. This week, we look at another encounter, this time with a Samaritan woman. It doesn’t seem accidental that John places these stories back-to-back. He is inviting us to examine them next to each other.

In the first, a Jewish man seeks out Jesus at night to avoid being seen with a teacher whose words and actions have unsettled religious leaders. He wants to avoid any association that could bring shame on him; he hides to protect his reputation. In the second, a Samaritan woman goes about her daily task of drawing water, but she does it in the heat of the day to avoid the shame attached to her life. She hides from whispers and judgment.

Both are hiding—just in different ways.

In both encounters, Jesus’ words cause confusion. To Nicodemus, he says, “You must be born again.” Nicodemus, thinking only in physical terms, asks how someone can be born twice. To the woman, Jesus says, “If you had asked, I would have given you living water.” She wonders how he could offer water when he has nothing to draw with. Jesus is speaking of deeper truths—being born of water and spirit to Nicodemus, and living water and true worship to the woman—but they only understand at surface level.

To each of them, Jesus reveals who he is. With Nicodemus, it comes through a subtle reference to the “Son of Man,” a term he would have recognized as pointing to the Messiah. With the Samaritan woman, there is no subtlety. He plainly declares, “I who speak to you am he.” This is where it gets really interesting! The woman believes. She understands that Jesus is the living water he has been describing—the One who can cleanse her, satisfy her, and change her story. Her response is immediate and public. This woman who came alone, steeped in shame to avoid people, excitedly runs off to tell everyone her good news. Nicodemus, however, slips back into the night; we aren’t told what he does next. (Though, John will show us later that his story isn’t over.) He came with questions and left with much to consider.

John shows us that Jesus meets each person where he or she is: knowledgeable and respected or empty and exposed. The difference isn’t intelligence. It isn’t status. It isn’t background. It isn’t even access. The difference is response.

Nicodemus left with more information; the woman left with a mission. At the end of the day, knowledge of the Messiah matters far less than your surrender to him. One man walked away; one woman followed. How are you responding?

PRAYER

Lord, thank you for meeting each of us where we are—whether in questions or in shame, in light or darkness. Open my heart and my understanding so I can respond with genuine surrender to all that you offer.

Jennifer Ayotte
Director, Communications

Read More Devotions

Explore other devotions like this one any time at crossings.church/devotions .